Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Evaluating Sources

Evaluating Sources




In Class Links:
Evaluating Sources PPT
Article Link
Journal Webpage

Resources:
Library Webpage
Purdue Owl: Annotated Bibliographies
Pudue Owl: Evaluating Sources

Google Scholar

In Class Activity:

In a Google doc evaluate one of your sources for assignment 4 and create an annotation for it. Share with me the MLA citation for your source, and the annotation. You may do this as a group or individual. You can use this opportunity to do many different sources and give your group a boost on its work for assignment 4, or just do one source if you aren't far enough in your research to do more. 

Remember to Consider:
Credentials of the publisher
Gate keeping processes involved in publishing
Credentials of the author
Date of publication
Stance of the source. What is the author’s purpose and how may it affect the conveyance of information?
Cross Reference the source- How do the people who cite this source use the source?

Homework:
Work on Assignment 4
Read: Rachael Carson: From Silent Spring, American Earth p. 366 by 4/3
Look ahead to assignment 5 now due 4/26 by end of day

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Aldo Leopold, Rick Bass, and The Role of Doubt

 

Do you think Ira Glass presented the issue fairly? Why or why not?
What is the role of doubt in argument?
Is doubt necessary? Why or why not?
How do you work to convince someone of your point of view who has doubt?
Who sees an argument as a he said/ she said argument?

This American Life Act 2:  25:55- 38:07

Homework:
Work on Assignment 4
Read: Read The Everyday Writer p. 168-192 by 3/29

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Paragraphs and Group Planning

Paragraph PPT


Paragraph Structure

Sample Paragraph 1

William’s use of word choice creates strong characters that the reader admires which add to the emotional appeal of her story. The first time she refers to the women in her family that have suffered from breast cancer, she calls them “a Clan of One-Breasted Women” (752). The title she gives this group of people suggests an image of warriors. She depicts these women not as victims, but strong fighters. Williams clearly admires these women through her description of her mother’s battle with breast cancer.  Her description is a description of royalty. Her mother is dressed like a queen in a purple velvet robe and holds herself with grace, elegance, and dignity despite her mastectomy.  Her wounds from the surgery are hidden (753). She never describes her mother or the other women from a place of weakness or pain. They are warriors and fighters eliciting admiration and from those around them. People so full of grace and dignity deserve justice and a voice. In this way, Williams causes us to feel emotion for these strong women through her eyes .




Sample Paragraph 2
Chabon also uses word choice as a technique. Word choice is another way to strike emotion or create a description. When he says, “though the wilderness available to me had shrunk to a mere green scrap of its former enormousness ” this is filled with word choice. “Shrunk to a mere green scrap of its former enormousness” hits the audience hard, and makes so much sense.  Chabon did a great job with word choice in getting that point across.



Paragraph activity:
1. Form small groups. Read and discuss the example paragraphs. Underline the topic sentence and concluding sentence. Number the pieces of general support. Circle the second-level support and specific details. Identify transitional phrases and words. (you may do this on a word document and share it)

2. For each paragraph draw a model, structure, or image that represents the structure of the example paragraphs, including the topic sentence, levels of support, transition, and concluding sentence. If necessary, consider providing a "key" or other labels that explain how the model "works." (you may do this in a computer program or by hand and turn it into me on paper, or add it to the word document)

3. Share and discuss your paragraph model with the other groups. Hand it into me.



Group Planning Activity:
Your Task: Post to your group forum on Blackboard a written statement that should include:

1) Declare your topic and how it qualifies as a local, place-based issue. State whether you will write an argument of fact or a proposal.

2) Include a list of steps you need to take in order to accomplish this assignment as well as a goal date when you will have these steps accomplished timeline for accomplishing these steps.

3) State your preference for presentation day (April 10th or 12th). You won’t necessarily get your preference.

4) Division of Labor: What tasks do you need to do together? How can you evenly divide the work? Pay special attention to how you might make a research paper that is cohesive and consistent in tone and organization with all group members. Write a paragraph explaining your plan for fairly dividing work.

Remember, your issue needs to be researchable, and small enough for you to handle in the research paper.  You may choose a larger issue (for example: a scarcity of affordable fresh produce in the US) if it is connected to a local issue (for example: no fruits and vegetables for struggling families where you live).

Sharing Information: you will want to exchange contact information. Remember that you can communicate using Google docs to share information and files. Some groups in the past have even planned their projects via Facebook.

Share this information with me in a word document by Friday 3/23.

Homework:
Work on Assignment 4

By Tuesday 3/27
Read Rick Bass: From The Ninemile Wolves American Earth p.760-769
Read Aldo Leopold: From A Sand County Almanac “Thinking Like a Mountain” American Earth p. 274-276  

By Thursday 3/29
Read The Everyday Writer p. 168-192 by 3/29




Monday, March 19, 2012

Daniel Quinn and Group Work

Daniel Quinn
 

 

In Class Activity

Contrary to popular belief, there most certainly is an "I" in "team."  It is the same "I" that appears three times in "responsibility."  
~Amber Harding

Bad Apple Behavior This American Life

In Class Activity:
As individuals, take some time to jot down ideas you have for how you would address the questions below. Then, come together with your group and decide on the best course of action. Write down your answers on one piece of paper per group, and be prepared to share with the rest of class.

What would you do if:

1) A member of your group comes to a group meeting unprepared, says nothing unless addressed directly and then mostly says yes or no. He gets out his phone and starts texting during group discussion.

2) One group member tells another, he is wrong and that he doesn’t know what he is talking about. She then physically turns away from him and tries to exclude him from the conversation. When he gives an idea, she says the idea won’t work but doesn’t give any alternative solution.
3) One group member comes with only part of his task completed. He expresses doubt that the project is achievable. He says that he doesn’t understand the part of the assignment he is supposed to be working on and thinks it is a boring  issue to research.
4) One group member arrives to a class work session frustrated and stressed. She makes comments that suggest she thinks her part of the project is more than her fair share of work. She has picked up the part of the project that an absent group member was supposed to do and has not done.

Homework:
1) Read: Daniel Quinn Excerpt from Ishmael –electronic by 3/20 ***Please print out or bring to class on your laptops and be ready to discuss***
2) Read: The Everyday Writer p. 68-82 by 3/23
3) Work on Assignment 4 with your group.


Thursday, March 8, 2012

Michael Pollan and Fallacies of Argument

***Please bring your yellow Everything's and Argument and your American Earth Reader to class***

GROUP SIGN-UP SHEET

Michael Pollan


Fallacies of Argument Game
Prior to the game, review Chapter 17, Fallacies of Argument, your reading for Tuesday.

Homework:

1) Optional Reading for Assignment 4: Everything’s and Argument chapter 8 or 12 depending on your groups chosen type of writing

2) Read: Daniel Quinn Excerpt from Ishmael – electronic by 3/20 ***Please print out or bring to class on your laptops and be ready to discuss***

3) Read: The Everyday Writer p. 68-82 by 3/23

Monday, March 5, 2012

Peer Response

GROUP SIGN-UP SHEET
Use this sheet to reserve your groups.

*** Please bring a draft of assignment 3 to class for peer response. If you don't have a draft, I will be disappointed, but I hope you will still come to class.***






In-Text citations answer sheet
Peer Response sheet

Homework:
March 8th:
Assignment 3 Due Thursday March 8th posted to Blackboard by end of day.
Please bring Everything's an Argument to class Thursday

After Spring Break:


1) Optional Reading for Assignment 4: Everything’s and Argument chapter 8 or 12 depending on your groups chosen type of writing

2) Read: Daniel Quinn Excerpt from Ishmael – electronic by 3/20 ***Please print out or bring to class on your laptops and be ready to discuss***


3) Read: The Everyday Writer p. 68-82 by 3/23